THE SHORT ANSWER
Review a mahjong sample as the collection your customer will actually receive. Count the agreed inventory, examine readability and consistency, measure the tiles, check the actual racks and mat, and pack every included component into the selected storage and outer packaging. Record each decision as APPROVE, REVISE or HOLD against a named sample and specification version. This is a proposed buyer review method, not a claim that a particular sample has passed inspection or that every production unit is certified.
Product arrangement; not an inventory diagram or a customer endorsement. Finished specifications require sample approval.
Bring the agreed version to the review
Use the face-by-face tile inventory, approved front and back artwork, proposed dimensions, material and color references, and component list. Identify the physical sample and the person recording the review. Keep the intended user group and target market in the brief: sample appearance alone cannot determine which safety documents may be needed.
The supplied inventory worksheets are planning tools. Check which playing tiles, extras, racks, pushers, mat, storage and small accessories belong to your agreed order. Do not treat an illustration as a packing list.
Make each check observable
| Check | How to review | What to record or resolve |
|---|---|---|
| Tile inventory | Count each face and compare the count with the agreed inventory; list extras separately | Inventory revision, missing/extra identities and a count record |
| Face readability | Review the proposed artwork at finished size with intended users at their normal table distance | Specific confusing identities or marks; artwork revision and viewing conditions, not a claimed accuracy percentage |
| Backs and appearance | Compare backs, edges and visible finish across the sample set under the same lighting | Photos tied to the sample and physical color reference; differences requiring agreement |
| Dimensions | Measure height, width and thickness using an agreed method | Measured values, units, instrument/method and agreed tolerances; do not invent a universal tolerance |
| Rack and pusher fit | Place the actual tiles on the intended racks and check stability, usable space and pusher movement | Rack version, tile dimensions and any obstruction or instability |
| Mat use and packing recovery | Lay the mat on the intended table surface; move tiles/racks and inspect its condition after the proposed packing method | Surface and packing method; observed flatness, movement and edge issues without unsupported durability claims |
| Loaded storage | Pack all agreed components in the bag or box and close it without forcing the contents | Loaded arrangement, usable space, contact between hard components and access to pieces |
| Retail and transit packing | Compare the included components, labels and protective packing with the agreed pack-out | Packing version, photos, unresolved protection requirements and any separately agreed transport tests |
Use the existing worksheet instead of a second checklist
The existing worksheet groups the record into artwork and identity, inventory and dimensions, color and construction, compatibility, packaging and dispatch, and release records. Put the observations from the checks above into those sections. Attach photographs and measurements using the sample reference and file revision so another reviewer can follow the decision.
APPROVE should identify exactly what is accepted. REVISE should name the change and the evidence needed for another review. HOLD should identify the unresolved decision and who must resolve it. Agree how component-level approvals relate to the final production release; one accepted feature must not silently approve the whole order.
Reconfirm the parts affected by a change
Changes to tile dimensions or thickness should trigger a review of rack and storage compatibility. Changed artwork needs review at the intended finished size. A new material, finish, color reference, component count or insert layout may also affect earlier approval decisions.
Ask which items require a revised physical sample and which can be resolved through documented evidence. Record the decision rather than promising that a photograph always replaces a sample. A packing change should be checked against the fully loaded arrangement, not only the empty bag or box.
Keep the retained sample, approved files and written exceptions together. Before production release, confirm the inspection scope, acceptance conditions, responsibilities and procedure for reporting a mismatch. The sample review and production inspection are related records, not interchangeable proof.
Buyer questions
Can I approve a collection from a single product photograph?
A photograph can document appearance, but it cannot establish the complete inventory, physical dimensions, rack fit or loaded storage arrangement. Decide which checks need physical components and which supporting evidence is acceptable.
Can one component be approved while another is revised?
Yes as a recorded review status, provided both parties agree what it authorizes. Name the accepted component/version and keep the open change visible; do not interpret partial approval as an unrestricted production release.
Does sample approval prove certification or the quality of every unit?
No. Sample approval records an agreed reference and scope. Any test report must be checked for its holder, date, covered product/material and method. Production evidence and order-specific inspection records remain separate.
Sources and limits
The review structure follows the site’s published sample-approval pack and quality-planning guidance. A public player discussion about oversized tiles and rack fit provides context for the compatibility question; it is not a test of Mahjong Atelier products.
No measurements, defect rates, certification results or completed customer project are claimed here. Project-specific tolerances, test methods and acceptance criteria must be agreed from the actual specification and applicable requirements.
KEEP THIS CHECKLIST
- List each product and quantity per color and size
- Record specifications, packaging and unresolved items
- Agree project-specific sampling and production timing
- Keep the accepted quotation and sample approval record
Sources & context
- Ordering terms and confirmed scopePublisher commercial terms; owner confirmed 2026-10-08 · Accessed 2026-10-08
- Sample approval worksheetPlanning template, not a completed inspection · Accessed 2026-10-08
- Quotation comparison worksheetScope comparison template; no price promise · Accessed 2026-10-08
Forum excerpts are qualitative feedback. Product specifications describe linked products only. Recommendations are editorial judgments, not lab results or statistical popularity rankings. Editorial policy.
